MTG Gift Ideas: Unique Presents Magic: The Gathering Fans Will Actually Love

Shopping for someone who lives and breathes Magic: The Gathering? Whether they’re deep into Commander, love cracking packs, or just play for the lore and the vibe, there’s no shortage of amazing gift options out there—especially from artists and crafters on Etsy, where handmade and custom creations bring the game to life in unexpected ways.Here’s a guide to the kinds of gifts that MTG players really appreciate—things that go beyond booster packs and show you put real thought into what they enjoy.

Top Picks for Magic Players

Custom Playmats That Stand Out

Playmats are more than just table protection—they’re a reflection of personal style.

Art they love – Whether it’s a favorite planeswalker, their own OC, or a beloved pet turned into a planeswalker, custom art mats are always a hit.

Double-sided designs – Perfect for players who switch up decks or want something fresh mid-match.

With zones marked – Super helpful for newer players or anyone who likes their board tidy.

Deck Boxes They’ll Want to Show Off

Anyone who plays regularly knows how much a good deck box matters.

Wood or leather craftsmanship – These boxes look fantastic and age well.

Magnetic lids and secret compartments – A mix of practicality and style.

Inspired by MTG lore – Whether it’s Ravnica guilds, mana colors, or iconic characters, themed boxes add a nice personal touch.

Creative Accessories They Didn’t Know They Needed

Small things can make a big impression.

Life counters with flair – Think carved dials, custom dice, or painted minis that double as trackers.

Sleeves with personality – Handmade or printed with custom artwork, these are way cooler than standard ones.

Tokens and counters – Getting a full set of matching tokens is a dream, especially for players who run tribal or token-heavy decks.

Collector Pieces for the Fans Who Have Everything

Looking for something truly memorable?

Altered art cards – These are hand-painted versions of real cards, often turning game pieces into one-of-a-kind collectibles.

Foil peel alters – Artists carefully remove and redesign the foil layers of cards—stunning and unique.

3D printed or sculpted life trackers – Great for Commander tables and look great on a shelf too.

Personalized Gifts with a MTG Twist

Some gifts say, “I know exactly what you like.”

Sleeves with their name or signature card – Ideal for Commander players who love a bit of flair.

Playmats printed with their decklist – A snapshot of a deck they love, immortalized as a mat.

Jewelry inspired by the game – Think subtle mana symbols or earrings shaped like emblems.

Where to Find These Magic Gift Ideas

Most of the best stuff comes from independent creators. On Etsy, just search “MTG gifts” or check out sellers like MTGet, where everything is made by fans, for fans. Many shops offer made-to-order options too—great if you want something truly tailored.

Final Tip:

Before you click ‘buy,’ take a moment to think: what colors do they play? Who’s their favorite commander? Do they lean casual or competitive? A gift that nods to that will feel way more personal.

Got a go-to Magic gift you’ve given (or gotten)? Drop a comment and let others steal your idea!