Where Can You Buy MTG Proxy Cards That Look and Feel Real? Try MTGetsy

Are You Looking to Buy MTG Proxy Cards But Unsure Where to Start?
Magic: The Gathering is one of the most iconic trading card games in the world. It has captivated millions of players across the globe with its deep lore, strategic gameplay, and stunning card artwork. However, with the ever-expanding sets and some cards fetching sky-high prices, building your dream deck can quickly become a financial challenge. That’s where MTG proxies come into play—and no one does proxies quite like MTGetsy, the leading MTG Etsy store for personalized and premium MTG items.

So, what are MTG proxies, and why should you buy them from MTGetsy?

What Exactly Are MTG Proxy Cards?

A Magic: The Gathering proxy is a substitute for a real MTG card. It is typically used in casual gameplay, cube drafting, and playtesting. While it’s not allowed in most sanctioned tournaments, proxies are widely accepted in non-competitive environments or house rules. They look and feel very similar to official MTG cards but are made independently, often customized, and most importantly, far more affordable.

Why Buy MTG Proxy Cards from MTGetsy?

MTGetsy is not just another Etsy store selling proxies. It is a dedicated platform for high-quality, customizable Magic products, including MTG proxies, trays, apparel, playmats, and more. Here’s why thousands of players trust MTGetsy when it comes to their proxy needs:

1. Affordable Prices Without Compromising Quality

MTG cards—especially vintage or legendary ones—can cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars. For example, cards like Black Lotus or Underground Sea are notoriously expensive and nearly impossible for the average player to own.

MTGetsy allows you to buy MTG proxy versions of these cards at a fraction of the cost, without sacrificing card thickness, feel, or print quality. That means you can play with your dream deck while keeping your wallet happy.

2. Exceptional Print Quality & Authentic Feel

Not all proxies are made equal. Some low-quality proxies have washed-out colors, blurry fonts, or incorrect dimensions.

MTGetsy uses professional-grade printing technology, ensuring:

Crisp, high-resolution artwork

Correct font spacing and layout

Near-identical sizing and texture

Gloss or matte finish options

The result? A proxy card that looks and feels just like the real thing—so much so, you’ll hardly notice the difference during gameplay.

3. Customizable Artwork and Text

Want to turn your favorite card into a custom piece of art? Or maybe you want a foil-style proxy or alternate language version?

At MTGetsy, customization is a breeze:

Choose from existing art templates

Submit your own artwork or text

Add foil effects, watermark logos, or alternate languages

Customize names, flavor text, or mana symbols

Whether you’re building a thematic Commander deck or just want a more personalized setup, MTGetsy brings your vision to life.

4. Perfect for Testing, Teaching, and Collecting

When Should You Use MTG Proxies?
Playtesting a Deck Before Spending Big: Want to test your Modern or Commander deck without investing upfront? Proxies are ideal for trying various builds before buying actual cards.

Protecting Valuable Cards: Own a rare or valuable card? Use a proxy in casual games to keep the real one safe in storage or a display binder.

Cube Drafts and Custom Formats: Cube drafting is one of the most fun formats in MTG, and proxies allow for an even spread of powerful and balanced cards without a massive investment.

Teaching New Players: New to Magic or teaching a friend? Use proxy cards to teach the basics without fear of damage or misplacement.

5. Fast, Reliable Shipping and Excellent Customer Service

Unlike other stores that take weeks to deliver or don’t communicate clearly, MTGetsy offers:

Prompt shipping through trusted logistics partners

Regular order tracking and delivery updates

Responsive customer support for custom requests or order issues

Secure packaging to ensure your proxies arrive in mint condition

You can rest assured that your proxies will be delivered on time and in perfect shape.

6. Trusted by the MTG Community

With hundreds of five-star reviews and return customers, MTGetsy has earned a strong reputation within the Magic community. Many customers return to MTGetsy not just for proxies, but for personalized MTG trays, tournament accessories, MTG apparel, and more.

Players love:

The premium product feel

The artistic customizations

The level of detail in communication

The competitive pricing structure

If you’re unsure where to buy MTG proxy cards online, MTGetsy is a community-approved, artist-owned brand you can trust.

How to Order MTG Proxy Cards from MTGetsy
Ordering from MTGetsy is simple, secure, and flexible:

Step-by-Step Process

Visit the MTGetsy Store
Head to the MTGetsy Etsy shop to browse existing proxy options or reach out for a custom design.

Browse or Request a Custom Order
You can explore existing proxy collections (standard, foil, full-art, alt-art), or use the custom order feature to send in your request.

Select the Condition and Card Type
Choose between foil, non-foil, matte or glossy finishes, and whether you want custom backs or standard MTG backs.

Add to Cart and Checkout Securely
Finalize your order using secure Etsy payment options. You’ll receive confirmation and a tracking link once your order is shipped.

Wait for Delivery and Enjoy!
Depending on your location, you can expect your proxies in 5–10 business days.

Conclusion

Whether you’re a veteran looking to test new strategies, a budget-conscious player building your dream deck, or a newcomer learning the ropes, MTG proxy cards are a great tool—and MTGetsy is the ideal place to get them.

Their dedication to quality, customization, affordability, and customer care makes them stand out as the top MTG Etsy store for proxy cards and other Magic-related gear.

So, why wait?

Visit MTGetsy today and bring your perfect deck to life—without breaking the bank.